|

1997:
| Pos. |
First Team |
Second Team |
|
G |
Dominik Hasek, Buffalo Sabres |
Martin Brodeur, New Jersey Devils |
|
1st D |
Brian Leetch, New York Rangers |
Scott Stevens, New Jersey Devils |
|
2nd D |
Sandis Ozolinsh, Colorado Avalanche |
Chris Chelios, Chicago Blackhawks |
|
LW |
Paul Kariya, Anaheim Mighty Ducks |
John LeClair, Philadelphia Flyers |
|
C |
Mario Lemieux, Pittsburgh Penguins |
Wayne Gretzky, New York Rangers |
|
RW |
Teemu Selanne, Anaheim Mighty Ducks |
Jaromir Jagr, Pittsburgh Penguins |
1996:
| Pos. |
First Team |
Second Team |
|
G |
Jim Carey, Washington Capitals |
Chris Osgood, Detroit Red Wings |
|
1st D |
Chris Chelios, Chicago Blackhawks |
Brian Leetch, New York Rangers |
|
2nd D |
Ray Bourque, Boston Bruins |
Vladimir Konstantinov, Detroit Red Wings |
|
LW |
Paul Kariya, Anaheim Mighty Ducks |
John LeClair, Philadelphia Flyers |
|
C |
Mario Lemieux, Pittsburgh Penguins |
Eric Lindros, Philadelphia Flyers |
|
RW |
Jaromir Jagr, Pittsburgh Penguins |
Alexander Mogilny, Vancouver Canucks |
1995:
| Pos. |
First Team |
Second Team |
|
G |
Dominik Hasek, Buffalo Sabres |
Ed Belfour, Chicago Blackhawks |
|
1st D |
Chris Chelios, Chicago Blackhawks |
Ray Bourque, Boston Bruins |
|
2nd D |
Paul Coffey, Detroit Red Wings |
Larry Murphy, Pittsburgh Penguins |
|
LW |
John LeClair, Philadelphia Flyers-Montreal Canadiens |
Keith Tkachuk, Winnipeg Jets |
|
C |
Eric Lindros, Philadelphia Flyers |
Alexei Zhamnov, Winnipeg Jets |
|
RW |
Jaromir Jagr, Pittsburgh Penguins |
Theoren Fleury, Calgary |
